Tips for Interviewers

Tuesday, March 20th, 2012|

Helping candidates prepare for interviews is a big part of what recruiters do each day.  However, in screening and qualifying candidates for a variety of positions, recruiters are usually also experts at how to interview too.

Some of the things we’ve previously discussed on our blog – like body language – apply to interviewers as well as interviewees.  However, there are also posts, such as questions interviewers can’t ask in an interview, that are just for you.

We decided to give interviewers a few more tips for finding the perfect candidate:

    • Prepare – Make sure you know ahead of time what you plan to ask the candidates and how you will describe your company and the role.  Don’t hesitate to bring notes and be sure to keep the tone positive.

 

    • Listen – Active listening is essential to getting the information you need. Make eye contact with the candidate and listen to their tone – as well as their words.
    • Ask open-ended questions – Questions that start with “How”, “Why” or “Can you explain” are great ways for candidates to tell a story about something they’ve done in the past. Stay away from “yes or no” questions that stop the flow of the interview.

 

    • Keep track of time – Always leave time in an interview to address any questions the candidate might have about your company and the role.  This will give you some insight about what’s important to them.

 

  • Arrange next steps – If an interview goes well and you think you could have the right person on the other side of the desk, don’t be afraid to tell them.  Enlighten them on your current interview process and set up a second interview with other hiring authorities or team members, if appropriate.  If the interview did not go well – or it’s too early in the process to determine a fit – let the candidate know when a decision will be made about next interview rounds or hire(s).

The right hire can make a huge difference to the success of your business; the wrong one can stop progress in its tracks.  A good recruiter can help you find candidates with the right credentials and experience, but only you can decide who is the best person to add to your team.

Wendy Stackhouse Artisan Creative

Your Mother Was Right – Thank You Notes are Necessary!

Tuesday, March 13th, 2012|

 In today’s job market, getting an interview – making it past the initial resume culling process – is an achievement in itself.  But where, in the past, making the cut would lead to a face-to-face interview, hiring managers often have too many qualified candidates for most positions.  As a result, candidates are more and more likely to get a phone screen or Skype interview first.

Whatever the type of interview you have, follow-up is the most important thing if you want to keep your name at the top of the “maybe” list.   It is the only way to be noticed when hiring managers are overrun, with so many people to consider.

Here are some tips on what to do AFTER you talk to that hiring manager:

  • An email thank you is appropriate for a phone interview or an in-person interview with a very quick turnaround time on a decision.  An email thank you also gives you the opportunity to include a relevant link to a story or article that builds upon what you discussed in your interview–a great way to highlight your attention to detail and interest in both the company and the role.
  • A handwritten thank you is essential after an in-person interview.   Snail mail may seem dated, but the time it takes to write a note is very much appreciated and remembered.  The type of note you select can also demonstrate a bit of your personality as well.
  • Always have your References ready, but don’t provide them unless and until they are requested.  A thank you note or email is usually NOT the best place for relaying this information.

I’m willing to bet Mom was right about a lot of things – but with regards to thank you notes – she couldn’t be more on track!  To stand out in the crowd of job seekers, write those thank you notes!

Wendy Stackhouse for Artisan Creative

8 Tips for Your Next Telephone Interview

Thursday, March 8th, 2012|

Telephone interviews can be one of the most uncomfortable parts of the job-seeking process.  Many employers use them regularly in their hiring process as a way to reduce costs and save time.  Most often they are used to disqualify candidates early in the process before further time has been invested by all parties.

There are usually 2 types of phone interviews:

The “screening call”.  Quite often the HR department needs to learn additional information about candidates before forwarding their application to the Hiring Authority. Although the initial contact can be quite unassuming, HR is most likely trying to “short-list” a stack of potentials for the position.

The “committee” telephone interview. Sometimes several hiring authorities or department staff will get together on the interviewing process so that they can share their conclusions afterward. This rarely happens when the company is still early in the process.  Rather, it usually occurs when there are too many qualified candidates for face-to-face interviews.

Depending on the nature of the person conducting the telephone interview, these calls can be either quite pleasant or extremely uncomfortable.  In either case, there are certainly several ways to best prepare yourself for a successful call:

    1. The person on the other end of the phone may be just as uncomfortable as you. Concentrate less on your feelings and more on how to make the other person feel at ease.

 

    1. Smile over the phone. Believe it or not, smiling while you talk will help you sound more friendly and open.
    2. You are not judged by the same criteria used at an in-person interview. For example, eye contact can be an excellent barometer when meeting face to face.  However, on the telephone, you’ll be judged by a more subtle set of factors such as the sound of your voice, your tone, your level of friendliness, and enthusiasm.
    3. Speak succinctly about your past experience and accomplishments. Many professionals launch into long, drawn-out answers to telephone interview questions.  Remember, you do not have your interviewer’s eye contact or other body language cues to monitor.  Clear, short responses will keep the person on the other side of the line engaged (and not put them to sleep)!
    4. Utilize “dead air” during a conversation; don’t fear it. Have a list of prepared questions about the company or position when caught in one of those spots. Although good communication is theoretically up to both of you, dead air is typically your responsibility to fill.
    5. Focus on your listening skills. You’ll find that your nerves will sometimes make this very difficult.  Simply close off all thoughts about whatever is going on around you and concentrate on the words and voice of the interviewer.  Take notes while you listen, if it helps you focus.

 

    1. Situate yourself properly before the call.  Because so much of your success in this situation is determined by your comfort in the surroundings, plan the interview for a time when you can speak privately, comfortably, and without distraction. Or, if the caller takes you by surprise, ask for five minutes to get organized, get their phone number and call them back.

 

  1. Don’t talk about issues related to compensation, company benefits, or any negative issues with your current employer. This is solid advice for any first-interview situation.  This initial touchpoint is to make enough of a connection to get to the in-person interview phase.

Do you have any tried and tested tips for phone interviews?

Need help preparing for your next Skype Interview?  Check out our Skype Interview Tips.

Eliminate the Negative: Tips on What to Avoid in a Job Interview

Tuesday, March 6th, 2012|

Whenever I have an interview coming up, I go through my preparation process.  By the time the interview arrives, I know exactly what I want to say, at least to the standard interview questions I’ve encountered before, and I’ve prepared questions to ask – if the topics don’t come up naturally.

However, it’s also a good idea to make a clear list of the subjects you would rather not discuss, and how you will handle the situation if and/or when these topics do arise.  Here are some ideas from the recruiters at Artisan Creative about things to avoid on your interview – and some positive alternatives:

Talent Manager, Laura Burns:

  • Avoid saying anything negative about your former employer. Rather, plan to talk about a good relationship you had with the company and how that helped you do a better job.
  • Don’t talk about your personal life, even if the interviewer does. It is very easy to get caught following their lead. Try to steer the conversation back to the workplace.
  • Don’t talk about salary or benefits right at the start. If you’re working with a recruiter, let them discuss those items for you. They can probably get you a better package and will most likely have more experience negotiating than you do.

Creative Recruiting Manager, Jamie Grossman:

  • Don’t take credit for a whole project – even if you think it sounds better. Instead, discuss your accomplishments and how you worked with all those involved in the project. Employers like to know that you are a good at collaborating, too.

Sr Account Manager & Recruiter, Carol Conforti:

  • Instead of “I hated my last boss,“ say “I did not share the management philosophy.”
  • If you didn’t get along with someone try “my coworkers and I had different ideas about how things should be done.”
  • Don’t look for a promotion before you get hired. However, you can say “I feel very capable of doing a great job; is there a career path for this role?”
  • Instead of “When can I get a raise?” try “What is the review process here?”
  • Avoid asking “Do people work hard or spend long hours here?” If you want to know, say, “What is a typical day like here?”
  • Always have a question ready. Even if you don’t really have any, try, “What are the next steps?”

And a recent addition to the team, Account Manager & Recruiter, Melinda Geniza:

  • Always put a positive spin on your challenging experiences and talk about lessons learned.
  • Don’t be too modest about your achievements or contributions on certain projects: Avoid statements like “this was just a little thing I did…”
  • Generalities when describing your work are not as effective as specifics. Use technical language and details when talking about your process.
  • Don’t come across like you aren’t interested in the job. Even if it’s not your dream job, you must be interested or you wouldn’t be at the interview. Interviewers can pick up on your lack of enthusiasm through body language and eye contact.

I hope you got the theme in these answers. As the song says, “Accentuate the positive!” Prepare yourself to talk about your previous employer, your experience and your hopes for working in the future in a positive light and your interview is sure to go well!

Wendy Stackhouse, for Artisan Creative

The Creative Interview

Tuesday, February 14th, 2012|

Most of us have interviewed for many different roles in our working lives, from our first summer job in high school (where they needed to know if we could mop floors) to interviews hours of testing to prove our skillsets were as solid as our resumes claimed.

We’ve talked a lot on our blog about how to prepare for a typical interview – and even for a more atypical one – but we’ve never talked about how a creative interview differs from a more general one. Nor have we really talked about what creative recruiters are looking for versus their counterparts in another field.

I asked the recruiters at Artisan: “How do you think ‘creative’ interviews differ from ‘regular’ job interviews?”

The answers were pretty consistent.

    • The portfolio is the number one factor during a creative interview. Whether the interviewer has already seen work samples via a website or a PDF, the design aesthetic and body of work are always the most important consideration.  However, further explanation of that work is always required.  Talent must be prepared to explain their portfolio fully.”Creatives must be able to walk us through their work, their involvement in producing that work, their challenges, their inspiration and the effectiveness the work had,” said Account Manager, Jess Bedford.  “The finished work is only part of the whole creative process.  Understanding how creatives work through that process, helps us better qualify talent for the culture and team fit.”
    • Creative rapport is essential.  As is often the case, initial interviews may not always be held with like-minded or department-based interviewers.  HR, for instance, may not understand the full creative processes as well as a Creative Director.  Therefore, establishing an interviewer’s level of understanding for one’s creative specialty is essential.  Do it upfront, too.  Therefore, when one gets to the portfolio review, you know which work will illustrate something relevant to their needs / interest, and how in-depth your review should be.

 

  • Past resume experience is not always the key factor.  What’s more important than the clients you’ve worked for is being able to demonstrate, through both paid and/or spec work, a keen eye for design and the ability to push the creative envelope.” For so many of our clients – the resume is second to the creative work,” said Carol Conforti, Sr Account Manager, and Recruiter.  “Many creatives make the mistake of only including work that’s been paid for and/or approved.  Some of the best portfolios I’ve seen include both finished work and the other concepts that the clients didn’t use.  Many even have concepts designers have ‘played with’ in their free time.”

What I take most from these answers (thanks, recruiters!) is how essential a portfolio is to the creative interview.  And being able to review that portfolio effectively is just as important!

But that’s only part of it.  Research, once again, turns out to be really helpful as well. Whatever you can find out before the interview about the company, about the job responsibilities, even about the background of the interviewer or their client, will help you present your portfolio in the very best light possible.

Wendy Stackhouse for Artisan Creative

I Don’t Think So: Illegal Job Interview Questions

Thursday, February 2nd, 2012|

I’m sure you join me in wishing that “Tell me about yourself” was against the rules, but while that question may be perfectly acceptable in any interview – there are some questions hiring managers are not allowed to ask you in an interview.

Most human resources professionals know better and will not make these mistakes.  However, interviews are often conducted by an inexperienced interviewer, perhaps a department head, small business owner, or other hiring authority, who doesn’t know that some topics are actually taboo. These questions generally fall into common areas of discrimination – like race, sexual orientation, age, and health status.

Employers are not allowed to ask questions that could determine your national origin:

  • Where were you born?
  • What is your native language?

Interviewers cannot ask questions that will reveal your marital or parental status:

  • Are you married?
  • Do you have children?
  • Do you plan to start a family?

Age discrimination can be a problem, too:

  • How old are you?
  • When did you graduate?

Religion can also be an issue for some employers:

  • Do you celebrate Yom Kippur?
  • What church do you go to?

Your health is your own business, not your employer’s:

  • Do you have a disability?
  • Do you have a chronic illness?

It is illegal to discriminate against you for being in the armed services or reserves:

  • Are you in the National Guard?

And what you do on your own time is private (as long as it’s legal):

  • Do you smoke?
  • Do you use alcohol?

You won’t encounter these questions often – again, most human resources pros are trained not to ask these questions. But you never know…

How to respond to an illegal interview question?

Well, that depends. I’ve been known to volunteer my age (if I think it’s an asset) or mention my kids (but I probably shouldn’t). I like to think of an interview as a conversation with someone I don’t know yet.

If you think the interviewer is trolling for inappropriate information on purpose, tell them they’re not allowed to ask that and politely move on to your next opportunity.

If you think they sincerely don’t know, are just being friendly without realizing they are doing something wrong, it’s a tougher call. I would probably smile, laugh a little and give them a quizzical, “Wow.  I’ve never been asked that in an interview.  Are you sure we’re supposed to talk about that?” and hope for the best!  Try moving the interview along if you can.

Not everyone has the best intentions and not everyone is fully trained.  My recommendation – Keep your wits about you, know the rules and listen to your gut!  If something feels off – you probably don’t want to work there anyway!

Wendy Stackhouse, for Artisan Creative

The Proust Questionnaire for Creatives

Thursday, January 26th, 2012|

 

You’ve heard of the Proust Questionnaire, I’m sure. Made famous in the back pages of Vanity Fair Magazine, it was named not for questions, but for the answers given by Marcel Proust to a set of questions asked by his friend Antoinette Faure.

I remember them best from a television show called “Inside the Actors Studio” where, at the end of every episode, host James Lipton would ask these questions of the famous actors he interviewed. His questions included: What is your favorite sound? What is your favorite curse word? If you weren’t an actor, what would you be instead?

Barbara Walters uses a variation of the Proust Questionnaire in her interviews – which, in turn, inspired us at Artisan.

I asked our Recruiters what Proust-like questions they would like to ask (or do ask) when they interview talent, and I love the responses!  Definitely a lot more interesting than the adage “Tell me about yourself”, the answers to these questions reveal aspects of a candidate’s personality that help hiring managers determine if someone is the right cultural fit for their position.

And so I bring you…(drum roll, please)…The Proust Questionnaire for Creatives

Some that aren’t too outside the box:

  • What is your definition of creative?
  • What is your ideal job and where?
  • What inspires you?
  • Who is your favorite designer?
  • Who is your favorite architect?
  • What is your favorite source of design inspiration (website, magazine, blog, etc)?
  • What projects have you worked on that you are most proud of and why?

Some that would be fun to answer, take some real consideration but still be job related:

  • Name 3 things you could not live without?
  • What is your favorite part of the day or favorite part of your job?
  • We used to have the drop shadow, now we have the reflective surface, what do think is next?
  • What keeps you motivated?

Some that might make me wonder what they’re looking for exactly:

  • Where is your ideal travel destination and why?
  • What 3 things that you use in everyday life should be designed differently?
  • What was the last book you read?
  • What is your favorite TV show or Movie?
  • What is playing on your iPod right now?

And a few that I’ve honestly never thought about before an interview (but maybe I should)!

  • In your time away from work, what do you do?
  • Are you doing what you love or doing what pays the bills?
  • If you were an animal, what would you be and why?
  • If you could invite three people (dead or alive) to dinner who would they be and why?
  • Do you believe in aliens?
  • What’s the most despicable act a creative supervisor has done/can do to you?

I’m definitely going to add some of these to my interview preparation list!

Granted – these are just some of the unusual questions potential hiring authorities could ask during an interview.  The best advice is to be prepared to answer these kinds of questions as honestly and calmly as possible. Guess that’s just one more reason to do some practice interviews with imaginative friends!

Wendy Stackhouse, Consultant for Artisan Creative

Social Networks Are Your Friend—But Not Your BFF

Tuesday, December 27th, 2011|

I’m the first person to evangelize for social media. I’m on Facebook and Twitter all day for work and personal reasons, my daughter uses it to get information about and help with her homework, we all find links to interesting stuff every day, right? I don’t want to miss a single photo of my cousin’s twins!

We’ve talked on our blog about how important it is to be careful on LinkedIn, but it’s easy to remember there since it is a social network for professional development and networking. With careful thought, the other social media platforms can be just as useful to a potential employer when they are deciding whom to interview.

When I have an interview, I search for the person I will meet everywhere—be sure they are doing the same. What are they finding about you?

Photos

Although you think you have tweaked your privacy settings so that you are safe, it is still never a good idea to post photographs of yourself in questionable situations which employers might be uncomfortable with. Facebook owns the rights to any photo you post and they change their privacy rules all the time, often without notice. You don’t want the wrong person searching for you at the wrong moment, so don’t post anything you wouldn’t want a potential employer to see.

Language
Free speech is great and blogs and social media platforms are places for us to express ourselves. However, using coarse language makes more of a statement than you might mean. There are also some taboo subjects you might want to avoid except with your personal friends: politics, race, and religion are only a few. These subjects are best kept to a very small circle.

Venting
As unappreciated as you felt at your previous employer, keep it to yourself online. A typical interview question like “How was your relationship with your last manager?” is a good guideline. Anything past generally positive, unless it was better than that, is something you should take a pass on.

Dishonesty

Make sure everything that refers to your employment history anywhere is strictly true. If a potential employer finds different information on different sites, they will wonder if you are being truthful anywhere.

Confidentiality
It is best to limit how you talk about previous employers to elements which specifically apply to your role there and your relationship with the company. Anything about the company itself, its plans or projects, is theirs to discuss, not yours.

It would be nice to think we could say whatever we like with no consequences on social media, but of course, it is no different from real life.

Think before you post!

Wendy Stackhouse, for Artisan Creative

Preparing for a Behavioral Interview

Tuesday, December 6th, 2011|

 In doing research for this article, I went back to basics.

What is a Behavioral Interview?

A Behavioral Interview is one in which the interviewer asks questions about past behavior in the hope of being able to predict how you would handle a situation at their company in the future.

An example of a behavioral interview question would be: Tell me about a time when you set a goal & achieved it.

This and other behavioral interview questions are the perfect opportunities to tell a great story. We have talked before on our blog about telling stories and here is where those stories come in handy.

During your general interview preparation, write out a few stories about specific events or projects which were very successful or fulfilling for you. Even something that didn’t work out perfectly can make a good story if you can talk about what you learned from it.

If you have been preparing for interviews very thoroughly, you will have compiled a list of stories from which to choose and can focus on a few for each interview. Read the job description again and see if any of your stories involve any aspects of that job and practice telling them.

Many people use a technique known as STARR to prepare for these kinds of questions. STARR provides an outline for your answer which ensures that you will hit all the important points and stay on track while telling your story. STARR stands for:

  • Situation – be specific about where you were and what you were doing.
  • Task – what you were trying to accomplish.
  • Action – what you did to accomplish the goal you were working toward.
  • Result – the outcome of your efforts.
  • Reflection – what you learned from your experience.

Practice moving from one of these elements seamlessly into the next. Be sure to point out positive results and reflections.

If you are prepared with a few relevant stories, you will never again be thrown by behavioral interview questions!

Wendy Stackhouse, for Artisan Creative

Body Language Tips for Creatives

Thursday, December 1st, 2011|

 Have you ever come out of a meeting with no clue how it went?  You feel like your presentation was clear and effective.  You know you were prepared and your materials were informative.

Maybe you were paying more attention to what you were doing than how your audience was reacting, but if you play it back in your head, you might have more of an idea of how your presentation was received.

You also might be able to make it work better!

If you can put some of your attention on watching your listeners, you can learn a lot about how your pitch is going and maybe even change it up midstream and close the deal.

Is your listener…

  • Leaning his head on his hand?  He is bored.  Change the pace of your presentation or ask a question to re-engage his attention.
  • Leaning forward in her chair?  She is interested.  Keep up what you’re doing.
  • Touching his ears?  You are connecting.  Give him more information.
  • Making a suggestion with her palms down?  This is no suggestion, this is what she wants.  Tell her how you can give her what she has suggested in a definitive way.
  • Making a suggestion with his palms up?  He is looking for a discussion of the issue and is open to your input as well as his own.
  • Putting her hand over her mouth?  She doesn’t believe what you’re saying.  This is a good time to offer some quantitative evidence or examples.

How about you?  What are you revealing with your body language and how can you make sure your messaging is what you want it to be?

Are you…

  • Slouching? Sit with your back touching the chair, but leaning forward a bit.  This projects confidence and engagement without seeming stiff or nervous.
  • Crossing your arms?  This makes you seem defensive or closed off.  Stop as soon as you realize it.
  • Restless? If you know you are a “wiggler,” it is a good idea to practice your interview or meeting with a trusted friend who can help you become more aware of your habits.  Restless behavior like twirling your hair or bouncing your knee can be distracting to your listener when you want them to hear what you have to say.
  • Making eye contact?  Great! Active listening is an important skill and keeps your mind on the question at hand.

Both you and your interviewer are getting more information from each other nonverbally than verbally.  If you are paying attention, you can control the information they are getting from you and understand the information they are giving you back.

Wendy Stackhouse, for Artisan Creative